Temporohyoid osteoarthropathy (THO), also known as middle ear disease or stylohyoid osteoarthropathy, is a progressive condition affecting the temporohyoid joint and surrounding structures in horses.
Overview and Clinical Importance
Temporohyoid osteoarthropathy (THO), also known as middle ear disease or stylohyoid osteoarthropathy, is a progressive condition affecting the temporohyoid joint and surrounding structures in horses. This disease is characterized by proliferative bone changes at the articulation between the stylohyoid bone and the petrous temporal bone, potentially leading to joint fusion, nerve damage, and fractures. THO represents an important differential diagnosis for horses presenting with facial nerve paralysis, vestibular dysfunction, or head-shaking and is a recognized cause of neurological disease on the NAVLE.
THO can affect horses of any age, breed, or gender, though it most commonly presents in adult horses. The condition may be unilateral or bilateral, with bilateral disease reported in a significant proportion of cases. Early recognition and appropriate treatment are essential for optimal outcomes.
| Bone |
Description and Function |
| Stylohyoid (paired) |
Largest bones of the hyoid apparatus. Articulate proximally with the temporal bone via the tympanohyoid cartilage. Run through the guttural pouches and can be visualized endoscopically. |
| Tympanohyoid (paired) |
Hyaline cartilage connecting the stylohyoid to the styloid process of the temporal bone. Forms a synchondrosis. Site of mineralization in older horses. |
| Epihyoid (paired) |
Small lentil-shaped bones that often fuse with the stylohyoid in adult horses. Present as separate ossification centers in approximately one-third of horses. |
| Ceratohyoid (paired) |
Connect via synovial joints to the epihyoid/stylohyoid above and the basihyoid below. Surgical target for ceratohyoidectomy. |
| Basihyoid (unpaired) |
Central bone embedded in the root of the tongue. Bears the lingual process which extends into the body of the tongue. |
| Thyrohyoid (paired) |
Connect the basihyoid to the thyroid cartilage of the larynx via synovial joints. Fuse with the basihyoid in older horses. |
Anatomy of the Hyoid Apparatus
The hyoid apparatus is a complex arrangement of bones that suspends the tongue, pharynx, and larynx from the skull. Understanding this anatomy is fundamental to comprehending the pathophysiology and clinical signs of THO.
Components of the Hyoid Apparatus
High-YieldThe temporohyoid joint is a SYNCHONDROSIS (hyaline cartilage connection), not a synovial joint. This is important because the joint naturally undergoes age-related mineralization and has limited motion, predisposing it to fusion and subsequent stress fractures.
Critical Anatomic Relationships
The temporohyoid joint is in close proximity to several critical structures:
- Cranial Nerve VII (Facial): Controls facial expression, eyelid closure, ear movement, and tear production
- Cranial Nerve VIII (Vestibulocochlear): Responsible for hearing and balance/vestibular function
- Petrous temporal bone: Houses the middle and inner ear; fractures can extend into the cranial vault
- Guttural pouch: The stylohyoid bone runs through this structure, allowing endoscopic visualization
- Tympanic bulla: Located medial to the temporohyoid joint; can be affected by disease extension
Board Tip - Memory Aid: "7-8 at the Gate" - Cranial nerves VII (Facial) and VIII (Vestibulocochlear) pass through the petrous temporal bone near the temporohyoid joint. When THO causes fractures, these nerves are damaged, producing the classic presentation of facial paralysis (CN VII) and vestibular signs (CN VIII).
| Theory |
Description |
| Otitis Media/Interna |
Hematogenous bacterial infection of the middle/inner ear spreading to the temporohyoid joint. This theory is supported by some cases showing concurrent otitis, though many horses lack evidence of active infection. |
| Degenerative Osteoarthritis |
Primary degenerative joint disease similar to other joints. Age-related changes in the tympanohyoid cartilage may predispose to this condition. Studies show increased THJ changes with age. |
| Guttural Pouch Infection |
Extension of infection from guttural pouch empyema or mycosis to the adjacent stylohyoid bone and temporohyoid joint. However, concurrent guttural pouch disease is rarely documented. |
| Repetitive Trauma |
Crib-biting behavior has been associated with increased THO risk in some studies. Repetitive tongue and hyoid movement may stress the temporohyoid joint. |
Etiology and Pathophysiology
The exact cause of THO remains incompletely understood. Several proposed mechanisms exist:
Proposed Etiologies
Pathophysiology
Regardless of the initiating cause, the disease process follows a predictable pattern:
- Inflammation and Proliferation: Bony proliferation develops around the temporohyoid joint and proximal stylohyoid bone
- Joint Fusion (Ankylosis): Progressive ossification leads to fusion of the temporohyoid joint, eliminating normal motion
- Mechanical Stress: Normal movements (swallowing, head turning, chewing, vocalizing) create stress through the fused joint
- Fracture: Stress fractures occur at the petrous temporal bone or stylohyoid bone
- Nerve Damage: Fractures damage CN VII and CN VIII, causing characteristic clinical signs
High-YieldThe key concept is the LEVER ARM effect - the hyoid apparatus acts as a lever, and when the temporohyoid joint fuses, normal tongue and laryngeal movements transmit force to the skull base, eventually causing fractures. This explains why clinical signs often develop acutely despite the underlying disease being chronic.
| Nerve Affected |
Clinical Signs |
| CN VII (Facial) |
Ear droop (auricular paralysis)
Lip droop with muzzle deviation away from affected side
Upper eyelid ptosis
Inability to blink (exposure keratitis)
Decreased tear production (keratoconjunctivitis sicca)
Feed impaction between cheek and dental arcade |
| CN VIII (Vestibulocochlear) |
Head tilt toward the affected side
Ataxia (vestibular ataxia - leaning/falling toward affected side)
Nystagmus (pathologic eye movements)
Circling toward the affected side
Hearing loss (permanent) |
| Other Signs |
Dysphagia (difficulty swallowing) - less common
Corneal ulceration secondary to exposure keratitis
Acute onset or rapid worsening (suggests fracture) |
Clinical Signs
Clinical signs of THO vary depending on the stage of disease and whether fracture has occurred. Signs are typically unilateral but bilateral disease occurs.
Early/Pre-Fracture Signs
- Pain or sensitivity when pressure applied to the base of the ear or throatlatch region
- Head tossing or shaking
- Reluctance to accept the bit or work in a frame
- Resistance to specific head positions under saddle
- Ear rubbing
- Non-specific behavioral changes
Advanced/Post-Fracture Signs
NAVLE TipOn the NAVLE, the classic presentation is an adult horse with ACUTE onset of unilateral facial nerve paralysis (ear droop, lip droop) AND vestibular signs (head tilt, ataxia). The combination of CN VII and CN VIII deficits should immediately suggest THO as a differential. Remember: "Floppy Face + Tipsy Horse = Think THO"
| Modality |
Findings |
Advantages/Limitations |
| Guttural Pouch Endoscopy |
Thickening/enlargement of proximal stylohyoid bone
Bony proliferation at THJ
Serous exudate from joint |
Sensitive for diagnosis
Can evaluate both sides
Safe in ataxic horses
Limited to proximal stylohyoid |
| Skull Radiography |
Increased opacity of petrous temporal bone
Thickening of stylohyoid bone
Stylohyoid fractures |
Widely available
Superimposition limits detail
VD view best but requires GA |
| CT Scan (GOLD STANDARD) |
New bone formation at THJ
Joint fusion/ankylosis
Temporal bone fractures
Tympanic bulla changes
Subclinical bilateral disease |
Most sensitive and specific
No superimposition
Guides surgical planning
Requires GA (risk in ataxic horses) |
| MRI |
Soft tissue inflammation
Middle ear fluid
Otitis media/interna |
Best for soft tissue
Identifies concurrent otitis
Less available, requires GA |
Diagnosis
Diagnosis of THO relies on clinical signs, neurological examination, and imaging. Multiple modalities may be needed for definitive diagnosis.
Clinical Examination
- Complete neurological examination: Assess cranial nerves, particularly CN VII and CN VIII function
- Palpation: Check for pain at the base of the ear and over the basihyoid bone
- Ophthalmologic examination: Evaluate for corneal ulceration, tear production (Schirmer tear test), palpebral reflex
- Otoscopic examination: May reveal external ear canal abnormalities in some cases
Diagnostic Imaging
High-YieldALWAYS examine BOTH guttural pouches - THO can be bilateral even when clinical signs are unilateral. CT is the gold standard because it can detect subclinical contralateral disease, temporal bone fractures, and tympanic bulla changes that cannot be seen on endoscopy or radiography.
| Drug Class |
Examples |
Rationale |
| Antimicrobials |
Potentiated sulfonamides (TMS)
Ceftiofur
Enrofloxacin
Chloramphenicol |
Treat possible otitis media/interna; broad-spectrum coverage; 4-6 week course recommended |
| NSAIDs |
Flunixin meglumine
Phenylbutazone |
Anti-inflammatory and analgesic effects; reduce inflammation near fracture site |
| Corticosteroids |
Dexamethasone (short-term) |
Reduce acute inflammation; use cautiously and short-term only |
| Neuropathic Pain |
Gabapentin |
Adjunctive analgesia for neuropathic pain component |
| Antioxidant |
DMSO |
Anti-inflammatory; used in acute neurological cases |
Treatment
Treatment of THO involves both medical and surgical approaches. Studies show that surgical intervention results in better outcomes than medical management alone.
Medical Management
Ocular Management
Corneal ulceration secondary to CN VII dysfunction requires aggressive treatment:
- Topical antibiotics for corneal ulceration
- Artificial tears/lubricants for keratoconjunctivitis sicca
- Temporary tarsorrhaphy (surgical eyelid closure) in severe cases
- Conjunctival flap or corneal graft for non-healing ulcers
Surgical Management
Surgery aims to reduce mechanical stress on the temporohyoid joint by interrupting force transmission through the hyoid apparatus. Current preferred procedure is ceratohyoidectomy.
NAVLE TipCERATOHYOIDECTOMY is the current preferred surgical treatment for THO. It can be performed in standing sedated horses, which is safer for ataxic patients who may have difficulty recovering from general anesthesia. Outcomes are good to excellent with 80% of previously athletic horses returning to their original use.
| Procedure |
Description |
Outcomes/Considerations |
| Ceratohyoidectomy (PREFERRED) |
Complete removal of the ceratohyoid bone. Can be performed under general anesthesia or in standing sedated horses. |
80% return to previous use
Lower risk of recurrence vs stylohyoidectomy
Standing procedure safer for ataxic horses |
| Partial Ceratohyoidectomy |
Partial removal of ceratohyoid bone. Variant technique with similar outcomes to complete removal. |
Similar outcomes to complete CHE
Rare reports of refusion |
| Basihyoid-Ceratohyoid Disarticulation |
Disarticulation at the basihyoid-ceratohyoid joint. Can be performed in standing horses. |
Newer technique
Good outcomes reported |
| Partial Stylohyoidectomy (Historical) |
Removal of part of stylohyoid bone. Older technique, now less commonly performed. |
Higher complication rate
Risk of lingual artery damage
Risk of regrowth/recurrence |
Prognosis
Prognostic Factors
- Early diagnosis and treatment: Key to positive outcomes
- Severity of neurological signs at presentation: More severe signs = worse prognosis
- Age: Older horses at diagnosis have reduced survival
- Bilateral disease: May require bilateral surgery; more guarded prognosis
- Corneal ulceration: Complicates management but typically resolves with treatment
- Hearing loss: Permanent; does not improve with treatment
High-YieldHearing loss is PERMANENT in THO cases with vestibulocochlear nerve damage. Horses can compensate visually for unilateral vestibular deficits, and vestibular signs may only be evident when the horse is blindfolded. Maximal improvement in neurologic deficits may take months to years.
| Treatment Approach |
Prognosis |
| Surgical Treatment |
Good to Excellent
80% return to previous athletic use
Ataxia typically resolves completely
Mild residual CN VII deficits may persist (21%)
Head tilt may persist but is not functionally limiting (43%) |
| Medical Treatment Only |
Fair
37% show improvement
Recovery may take 1-2 years
Neurological deficits more likely to persist
Risk of continued fractures if joint remains fused |
Differential Diagnosis
When evaluating a horse with facial nerve paralysis and/or vestibular signs, consider:
| Differential |
Distinguishing Features |
| Guttural Pouch Mycosis |
Epistaxis common; fungal plaques visible on endoscopy; involvement of carotid artery and cranial nerves IX-XII more common |
| Guttural Pouch Empyema |
Purulent nasal discharge; distended pouch on palpation; purulent material on endoscopy |
| Trauma to Facial Nerve |
History of trauma; facial paralysis without vestibular signs; no bony changes on imaging |
| Equine Protozoal Myeloencephalopathy |
Multifocal neurological signs; spinal cord involvement; positive serology/CSF testing |
| Skull Fracture |
History of trauma; acute onset; imaging shows fracture without THO changes |
| Intracranial Abscess/Tumor |
Progressive signs; may have other central nervous system deficits; CT/MRI diagnostic |